Dipartimento di Matematica del Politecnico di Milano
P.le Leonardo da Vinci 32, 20133 Milano, Italy
1 INTRODUCTION: THE INKA SACRED LANDSCAPE
Fig. 1 The ancient part of Cusco in the shape of a puma
The "navel" of the Inca world was thus perceived as a sacred space having the form of a living being, although, of course, it is difficult to assess today how much of this perception was "symbolic" [Zuidema 1983, 39-100]. As a matter of fact however, today's people living in rural villages in the Kaata region (at the border between Bolivia and Peru') still conceive their "heartland" as a huge human body, so it may happen that a man "of the head" reports that his wife "comes from the right hand" indicating their different villages by means of different locations in the "symbolic body" [Bastien 1985].
In addition to this "sacred geography", the urban
plan of the city was developed in accordance with a radial
perception of the sacred space as well. First of all, the town,
exactly as the whole Inka state or Tahuantinsuyu, was
divided into four parts, Chinchaysuyu and Antisuyu,
associated with hanan ("upper"), and Collasuyu
and Cuntisuyu, associated with hurin (below). Each
of the four "quarters" was in turn divided into 42
radial sectors, the lines between the sectors being called ceques.
The ceque lines converged at or near the main temple, the Coricancha,
and each line contained several huacas with a total of 328 (there
are strong hints pointing to the fact that other Inka towns,
such as Huanuco Pampa, were later planned on a similar basis,
thus becoming a sort of replicas of the capital [Morris and Thompson
1985]). Although one of the chroniclers, Bernabè Cobo
, gave a detailed description of this ``ceque system",
the identification of its elements today has proven to be quite
an hard task, and much effort has been devoted to it [Zuidema
1964; 1977]. In recent years, a wide fieldwork aimed to the identification
of all the huacas of the system has been done by Brian Bauer,
who succeeded in identifying more than a half of them (Fig. 2).
Fig. 2 An example of the structure of the ceque system: the first nine ceques of Antisuyu in Bauer's reconstruction (source: Bauer 1998).
I will not attempt to a review of Bauer's work, but only resume some relevant facts emerging from it which will be of importance in what follows:
Today, we have a reasonably clear picture of the role of the ceque system in the social organization of the capital. For instance, we know that the lines were divided in clusters of three types, reflecting the importance of the huacas and of the families who were in charge of keeping it "in efficiency" and of making offers to the shrines. In addition, as we shall see in more details below, we know that the system was deeply connected with the Inka sky-lore. However, if our understanding of the meaning and the structure of the system looks satisfactorily, the same cannot be said of our knowledge about the origin and the planning of the system. It is, in fact, pretty clear that a complex symbolic structure like the ceque system did not form spontaneously: it involved a huge planning fieldwork, during which some people were in charge of deciding the number of lines, the number of huacas, the type of huacas, and if a huaca had to be assigned to a ceque or to another. The aim of the present paper is to propose new possible relationships between the planning of the capital and the mathematical and astronomical knowledge of the Inkas.
2 INKA MATHEMATICS AND THE SACRED LANDSCAPE
Fig. 3. A Khipu. Museum für Völkerkunde, Berlin, Germany; photo by Gary Urton (source: the Khipu Database Project, Harward University)
There is no doubt that these devices were used at least to keep track of data in order to help the memory of their maker. For instance, if the maker of the Khipu was an exactor of taxes, he used it to record the type, the quantity, and the place where tributes were collected. This fact originated the point of view that Khipus were personal writings, that is, the idea that a Khipu was only a "help to the memory" and was thus readable only by its maker. However, this idea conflicts with many chronicles which, more or less clearly, state that the Khipus were a form of writing and, much more important, does not make justice to the Inka intelligence. Although the real extent to which some types of Khipus can be considered as a true form of writing is still debated, for the aim of the present paper it is sufficient the fact -- today well established -- that Khipus were used to store and transmit numerical data [Ascher and Ascher 1951; Ascher 2002; Urton 1988, 2003; Laurencich-Minelli 2004b]. Thus, Khipus were sufficient to record, for instance, architectural projects [Sapp 2000] and astronomical observations [Zuidema 1989]. Actually, in the chronicle Nuova Cronica y Buen Gobierno by Guaman Poma de Ayala, the Inka astrologer, "who studies the sun, the moon, and all other heavenly bodies in order to know when to plant the fields", is represented as a man carrying a fork-like observation instrument, and a Khipu (Fig. 4).
Fig. 4 The Inka astrologer, from Nuova Cronica y Buen Gobierno by Guaman Poma de Ayala, carrying a Khipu
All in all, it is reasonable to think that the structure of the ceque system was originally recorded in a Khipu [Bauer 1998], and it was actually noted already by the first chroniclers that the radial organization of the sacred space of Cusco corresponds to the "radial way of thinking" which inspires the Khipu mathematics. However, when looking at the distribution of the huacas in the ceque system one wonders about the fact that the huacas seem to have no logical, or "hierarchical" order. Thus, one may suspect that the lines were traced in such a way that different typologies of huacas were corresponding to different typologies of knots. As a consequence, I would like to propose here the possibility that the relationship between the ceque system and the Khipus was actually the inspiring motive of the whole system. In other words, there exists the possibility that the Khipu from which the ceques system was "copied on the ground" was carrying some information by itself. If this is true, than the radial plan of the city is actually a specific Khipu which contains specific data. Now, which kind of data could reasonably be recorded in it? The answer is likely to be a date, or a more complex information of calendar type. Indeed, the ceque system was deeply connected with the lore of the sky: some of the lines were astronomically oriented and marked relevant astronomical phenomena at the horizon, such as the rising of the sun at the solstices, and the system as a whole was connected with the Inka lunar calendar of 328 days based on a twelve sidereal month cycle [uidema 1977, 1988; Aveni 1981]. In addition, there are strong hints, to be discussed below, which points to a deeper relationship between the sky and the planning of the whole city of Cusco.
3 THE DARK CLOUD CONSTELLATIONS AND THE
Inspired by such considerations, and taking into account the astronomical interpretation of many aspects of the ceque system, it looks natural to investigate if also the sacred space of the Inkas had a celestial counterpart. As we shall see, it is likely that this counterpart was imagined as a dark cloud constellation of the Milky Way.
The Milky Way -- called Mayu -- was a central object in Inka astronomy and was individuated as a celestial counterpart of the Vilcanota river. The identification was so deep that actually the water flowing on the earth was thought of as the same water flowing in the celestial river and coming back to the earth in the rainy season [Urton 1982]. Many chroniclers, such as for instance Garcilaso de La Vega, report that the Inka identified animals in the sky in the region of the Milky Way. Up to the seventies, however, the identification of what scholars believed to be constellations in the sense we give to such a word, i.e. patterns formed in the sky connecting stars with lines, was not successful. In the meanwhile, nobody was giving the right credit to the chroniclers when they say that the Inka were actually viewing dark animals in the sky. Finally, the fundamental fieldwork carried out by Gary Urton with informants of the Quechua villages of Sonqo and Misminay, some 50 kilometres from the Inka capital Cusco, solved the enigma [Urton 1982].
The animals in the sky were not patterns formed connecting stars, but black regions of the Milky Way (dark clouds of interstellar matter, from the astronomer's viewpoint) whose contours were identified with contours of animals [Bauer and Dearborn 1995]. Urton was able to identify unambiguously the following dark cloud constellations (Fig. 5):
Fig. 5. The dark cloud constellations identified by Urton (Source: Urton 1982)
These dark constellations - in particular, the Llama and the Fox - are certainly the same identified by the Inkas more than six hundreds years ago [Bauer and Dearborn 1995]. In Urton's book however a further possible constellation appears:
The Choque-chinkay certainly belongs to the Inka lore of the sky as well, because it appears in a diagram depicted by Pachacuti Yamqui in 1613 (Fig. 6). In this diagram the author represents the objects which, according to him, were venerated in the Coricancha. I will not describe it in much details neither go trough the problem of its interpretation, but only notice some of its elements [Aveni 2001]. The space is vertically divided, and it contains stellar objects (for instance, Orion on the upper left, the Southern cross at the centre, seven Pleiades) solar system objects (the Sun, the Moon, Venus as morning and evening star) meteorological objects (the rainbow) natural "earthly" objects (the surface of the earth, the sacred tree).
Fig. 6. Diagram depicted by Pachacuti Yamqui in 1613
There is only one element which does not allow an immediate interpretation. It is the stylised figure on the middle right which is called Choque-chinkay and usually described as a "crying" feline. There is no doubt that "crying" figures like this were associated with the rain in the Andean world and, in particular, with the dark clouds promising a storm. However, a dual interpretation as a dark cloud constellation is not excluded by this. It has, in fact, been shown by Urton that the observation of the "darkness of the dark clouds" was used (and is still in use) to make predictions on the quantity of rain and therefore on the outcome of the seeding. But, where in the sky might this constellation be located? It is in fact difficult to accommodate a further dark constellation in the dark region inside the tail of Scorpio, already in part occupied by the Fox, as tentatively suggested in Urton's book. To try to understand where the Puma could be located, I will resort again to the sacred landscape of Cusco.
If the Inkas, as it looks reasonable, identified a Puma dark cloud constellation, perhaps the Cusco-puma layout was similarly meant as a replica of the "celestial puma". But Cusco was planned in such a way that the tail of the Cusco puma lies at the confluence of two rivers, and thus one is tempted to suppose that the celestial Puma should share the same property. Actually, all the dark cloud constellations identified by Urton are associated only with that "southern" part of the Milky Way which connects Scutum with Canis Major. This is the part of our galaxy which displays the brightest star luminosity and, as a consequence, a sharp contrast with the dark zones. It forms, at Cusco, a complete arc in the sky around midnight at the autumnal equinox, which is therefore the best period for viewing it. There is, however, a connection, shown by Urton, of the dark clouds with the rainy season (October to April), and the "northern" part of the Milky Way is clearly visible, in the beginning of the rainy season (October-November) divided into two branches, up to our Cygnus constellation where the two branches converge. According to one of Urton's informants:
I am, therefore, proposing that the Puma dark cloud constellation might be located in this "center", thus between Cygnus and Vulpecula (Fig. 7), exactly as Cusco was located in the "navel" of the world and at the confluence of two rivers.
Fig. 7. The Milky Way in the region between Cygnus and Crux, as viewed from Cusco in 1400 BC. The dark cloud constellations identified by Urton in this region have been sketched as an help to the eye. The huge region "between two rivers" which is comprised in the band connecting Scutum and Cygnus is indicated by arrows
4. CONCLUSION AND PERSPECTIVES
In this paper, a similar framework has been applied to analyse the Inca sacred space. The analysis which I have presented leads to conjecture that Cusco might have been conceived as a counterpart of a dark cloud constellation of the Milky Way and that its ceque system may have an astronomical counterpart as well, being a sort of "monumental" calendar Khipu. Of course, at present these proposals are speculative, and it is a duty for the author of a proposal to indicate which ways might be followed in order to verify (or disprove) it.
First of all, these ideas appear to be in sound agreement with the information we have about the Inca sky lore and the Inca perception of the sacred space. Since much of this tradition survives nowadays, further anthropological research should be carried out trying to clarify the position of the Puma constellation, whose existence is attested by the Pachacuti diagram and by Urton's informants reports.
Second, a possibility to check if the ceque system is "readable"
is to construct "tree diagrams" showing the possible
continuation of ceque lines between different adjacent huacas
as a function of the type of the huacas, trying to understand
the reasons of choosing each huaca for that specific ceque. This
research is in progress and, in my opinion, this study will be
of help, in any case, in order to understand the way in which
the planning of the ceque system was conceived. Finally, our
knowledge of Inca astronomy might be improved in any moment by
the discovery of new documents. This possibility has at least
a chance to become reality due to the ongoing study of a wide
set of recently discovered manuscripts written shortly after
the conquest, the so called Miccinelli Manuscripts (the
reader must be warned that not all scholars accept the authenticity
of such documents, although the case for authenticity is increasing)
[Laurencich-Minelli 2001]. Such documents appear to shed new
light on the Khipus [Zuidema 2003, 2004], and include the description
of a calendar Khipu and a copy of the Cusco ceque Khipu [Laurencich-Minelli
2004a]. Research is in progress in order to investigate which
kind of evidences, if any, can be extracted from such documents
regarding the proposals presented in this paper.
 Tom Zuidema, personal communication to the author. return to text
 Actually it may be that the existence of a terrestrial counterpart can be verified also for the Llama constellation. It was, in fact, stated personally to the author by many natives that, according to a old tradition, the 11 century fortress-sanctuary of Paramonga (north of Lima) was planned with the shape of a Llama, perhaps an image of the celestial one. return to text
Ascher M.e R. Ascher. 1981. Code of the Quipu: A Study in Media, Mathematics and Cultures. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
Ascher, R. 2002. Inka writing: Pp. 103-115 in Narrative Threads: Accounting and Recounting in Andean Khipu, J. Quilter and G. Urton eds. Austin: University of Texas Press.
Aveni, A. F. 1981. Horizon astronomy in Inkaic Cusco. Pp. 305-318 in Archaeoastronomy in the Americas, R. Williamson, ed. Los Altos, CA: Ballena.
______. 1996. Astronomy and the ceque system. J. Steward Anthropol. Soc. 24: 157.
______. 2001. Skywatchers. Austin: University of Texas Press.
______. 2003. Archaeoastronomy in the Ancient Americas. Journal of Archaeological Research 11, 2.
Bastien, J.W. 1985. Mountain of the Condor: Metaphor and Ritual in an Andean Ayllu. New York: Waveland Press.
Bauer, B. 1998. The Sacred Landscape of the Inka: The Cusco Ceque System. Austin: University of Texas Press.
Bauer, B. and D. Dearborn. 1995. Astronomy and Empire in the Ancient Andes: The Cultural Origins of Inka Sky Watching. Austin: University of Texas Press.
Bauval, R. 1989. A master plan for the three pyramids of Giza based on the three stars of the belt of Orion, Disc. Egypt. 13: 7-18.
Cobo, B. 1956. Historia del Nuevo Mundo (1653). Madrid: Biblioteca de Autores Espanoles.
Sarmiento de Gamboa, Pedro. 1999. History of the Incas. New York: Dover Publications.
de la Vega, Garcilaso. 1985. Comentarios reales. Caracas: Ayacucho.
Domenici, D. and V. Domenici. 2003. I nodi segreti degli Incas (The secret knots of the Incas). Sperling & Kupfer.
Eliade, M. 1959. The Sacred and the Profane: The Nature of Religion. London: Harcourt.
Hoskin, M. 2001. Tombs, temples and their orientations. Bognor Regis: Ocarina books.
Laurencich Minelli, L. 2001. Presentacion del documento "Exsul immeritus Blas Valera populo suo". In Guaman Poma y Blas Valera.Tradicion andina e istoria colonial. Proceedings of the International Conference, Rome, 29-30 September 1999. Francesca Cantù and Antonio Pellicani, eds. Rome.
______. 2004a. Quipu y escritura en las fuentes jesuiticas en el virreinato del Perù entre el final del siglo XVI y la primera mitad del siglo XVII. El Silencio protagonista. El primer siglo jesuita en el Virreinato del Perù: 1567-1667. Actas del Simposio Hist. 11: 171-212.
______. 2004b. Ulteriori prospettive per la
lettura dei quipu. Il quipu di Firenze n. 3887. Archivio per
l'Antropologia e l'Etnologia 84: 101-125.
Miccinelli, C. and C. Animato. 1998. Khipu. Il nodo parlante dei misteriosi inkas. Genoa: ECIG.
Morris, C. and D.E. Thompson. 1985. Huanuco Pampa: an Inca City and its Hinterland. London: Thames and Hudson.
Moseley, M. 2001. The Incas and Their Ancestors. London: Thames and Hudson.
Sapp, W.D. 2000. Design, Construction and Measurement in the Inka Empire. Pp. 133-145 in Nexus III: Architecture and Mathematics, K.Williams ed. Pisa: Pacini Editore.
Urton, G. 1982. At the Crossroads of the Earth and the Sky: An Andean Cosmology. Austin: University of Texas Press.
______. 1998. From knots to narratives: reconstructing the art of historical record keeping in the Andes from the Spanish transcriptions of Inka Khipus. Ethnohistory 45: 409-438.
______. 2003. Signs of the Inka Khipu. Austin: University of Texas Press.
Zuidema, R. Tom. 1964. The Ceque System of Cusco: The Social Organization of the Capital of the Inca. Leiden: Brill.
______. 1977. The Inca calendar. Pp. 219-259 in Native American Astronomy, A.F. Aveni, ed. Austin: University of Texas Press.
______. 1988. The pillars of Cusco: Which two dates of sunset did they define? Pp. 143-169 in New Directions in American Archaeoastronomy, A. Aveni, ed., BAR International Series 454. Oxford: British Archaeological Reports.
______. 2003. Los dias de la Epacta e Epagónimos en calendario pre-hispanicos y segun opinión de cronistas. Pp. 333-342 in Atti del Colloquio Internazionale Il Sacro e il Paesaggio, Davide Domenici, Carolina Orsini, Sofia Venturosi eds. Bologna: CLUEB.
______. 2004. El quipu dibujado calendarico llamado pachaquipu en el documento "Exsul Immeritus" de la colleccion Miccinelli. El Silencio protagonista. El primer siglo jesuita en el Virreinato del Perù: 1567-1667. Actas del Simposio Hist. 11: 171-212.
______. 1983. The lion and the city. J. Lat. Am. Lore 9: 39-100.
______. 1989. A Quipu calendar from Ica, Peru', with a comparison with the ceque calendar from Cuzco. Pp. 341-351 in World Archaeoastronomy, A. Aveni, ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
top of page
Copyright ©2005 Kim Williams Books